Wednesday, February 8, 2012

A New Gerald Desmond Bridge: Engineering That Can Inspire
by Brian Ulaszewski | Design In Place | 02.22.10 | 
| Text Size:
+

5:00am | As the Port of Long Beach looks to replace that crumbling piece of infrastructure known as the Desmond Gerald Bridge, we have a unique opportunity to create an architectural icon celebrating our port’s position as gateway to the Pacific. Like the current bridge, the new bridge will connect Interstate 710 to the Terminal Island port complex, thus being crucial to moving goods. The forty-year old bridge spans the length of a football field and has a clearance of over 150 feet. A source of growing concern, its deterioration has accelerated to the point that large chunks of concrete regularly fall from its roadway to the water below. The large net now slung under the bridge
ADVERTISEMENT
is literally a “band-aid,” temporary solution; a permanent solution is necessary.

This replacement bridge will be one-third higher than the current bridge, allowing a new generation of taller container ships to access the inner harbor area of the port. It will also be wider, featuring six lanes (plus shoulders) in contrast to the current four lanes. Crucially, however, the new bridge will be an improvement on the old not just in terms of function, but in terms of form as well: the utilitarian arched truss design of the current structure will give way to a slightly more elegant “cable-stayed” design. Renderings show a rather plain span linked by evenly spaced cables to a pair of tapering pylons. The design is, to be blunt, generic: it could be located anywhere from South Korea to the Mississippi. While undoubtedly an improvement, the new design lacks the dynamism and elegance appropriate for what will be the tallest bridge in Southern California.

We should treat this new bridge not just as a chance to “replace” something worn out, but as a rare opportunity to create a work of architecture both functional and graceful, a piece of infrastructure that can simultaneously stand as sculpture. We should create engineering that inspires.

In general, bridges are ideal for such visionary architecture. From the Gothic towers of the Brooklyn Bridge to the soaring arches of the Golden Gate Bridge, inspired designs have resulted in engineering achievements that are also international icons. Indeed, the American Society of Civil Engineers has declared the Golden Gate Bridge one of the Seven Wonders of the Modern World, alongside other grand achievements like the Panama Canal and the Empire State Building. The span attracts approximately nine million visitors a year above and beyond those using the bridge for their daily commuting.

Nearly a decade ago, the Norwegian Public Roads Administration used a graceful 500-year-old “pressed-bow” design by Leonardo da Vinci for new pedestrian bridge. According to Vebjørn Sand, the Norwegian public artist who led the effort to develop the ancient design, “Leonardo surmised correctly that the classic keystone arch could be stretched narrow and substantially widened without losing integrity by using a flared foothold, or pier, and the terrain to anchor each end of the span.” This pedestrian bridge, built of wood and granite, turned da Vinci’s vision of a poetic relationship between engineering and aesthetics into a reality for the first time.

Da Vinci’s contemporary, Santiago Calatrava, has reached international prominence as a sculptor who happens to be an engineer. His designs have been built around the world, from Lisbon to Milwaukee, and include a diverse portfolio of skyscrapers, bridges, obelisks, and train terminals. Calatrava is famous for his ability to design elegant works of art that are functional at the same time. Like the Golden Gate Bridge, many of Calatrava’s creations have become economic engines beyond what their functional purposes might suggest: they become both tourist attractions and symbols of the communities they serve.

Calatrava’s Sundial Bridge in Redding, California is a more dynamic version of the “cable-stay” structure proposed for the new bridge at the Port of Long Beach. The elegant design for the Sundial Bridge generated some controversy at the outset, competing as it did with a more traditional (and cheaper) alternative for a pedestrian bridge to span the Sacramento River in Redding. Calatrava’s design prevailed, and the higher price tag for the design was funded through a collaboration between the Federal Highway Administration, the Redding Redevelopment Agency, the Turtle Bay Exploration Park, and the McConnell Foundation. Completed in 2004, the bridge became an instant landmark, attracting visitors and media attention from across the nation. According to the Napa Valley Arts Council, the Sundial Bridge generated over 12,000 local hotel stays within two months of its opening. The Pittsburgh Post-Gazette even declared the Sundial Bridge one of California’s Seven Wonders, alongside famous structures like Hearst Castle and the Golden Gate Bridge.

As the Port of Long Beach prepares to invest over two billion dollars in port-related infrastructure, there has been little discussion as to how these massive projects will visually impact the surrounding community. The new Desmond Gerald Bridge will be the tallest structure within nearly a twenty-mile radius: the Port has a responsibility to the region to ensure the new space is visually compelling. Given that the bridge site lies within a Redevelopment Project Area and that it is public infrastructure, there should be a responsibility for part of the bridge’s budget to be dedicated to public art. Why not make the bridge itself the work of art? Why not create the largest piece of public art in Southern California? This is a critical time to move beyond a utilitarian perspective and imagine this new bridge as something more than just “infrastructure.” For the sake of our city, let us imagine it as an artist’s sculpture; let us create a bridge that inspires.

You have an opportunity to share your thoughts about the proposed new bridge at a Port of Long Beach-sponsored public presentation at 6:00pm on Wednesday, February 24, at Silverado Park (1545 W. 31st Street).


Comments
Click Here to Join the Discussion on this Story

15 Comments so far.
Rob
And while we are in a designing bridge phase, why not build one over Portuguese Bend.

E. Thor Carlson
This is brilliant Brian. Long Beach deserves a world class icon that we can pass down the generations; a work of art that will inspire our citizens for the next century. Let's do it, let's design the future, and not just build a bridge.

Cameron Crockett
Well stated Brian! I second the motion!

That_LB_Guy
BRAVO BRIAN! Your articles make SO MUCH SENSE! Imagine pictures of Long Beach with a stunning bridge structure... The Conv. and Visitors Bureau would certainly see an increase in visits. Businesses would locate nearby. Perhaps, even Pine Ave and the PIke could see a jump in occupancy! I can see residents taking the 110/Port route to bring visitors from LAX to LB just to traverse the graceful span of a sculpture on the water. Yes, the current plan is a definite improvement, but it is almost as "out of the box" in 2010 as the current one was 40 years ago. Keep thinking and proposing, Brian. Your creative ideas are helping to create a new, dynamic Long Beach that can and will be a model for other cities!

lbresident
mitigation for this project should include paying to reconfigure the breakwater

MikeBH
This bridge should be world-class, not anouther second rate job. Two of the items that should be included is a park at the base like their is in San Fransico and San Deigo and a bike path on the brige to connect the San Pedro waterfront to Down Town Long Beach.

JoeWeinstein
Brian generally has great ideas. If this project made sense, his ideas should guide it. But the project is very dubious. It exists only for the sake of a bigger port. In the short- and mid-term that aim will economically be far more risky than the LB Harbor Commissioners and LB Council and all local boosters want to admit: thanks to forthcoming expanded Panama Canal capacity. In the longer term, promotion of more far-reaching ocean and land commerce means simply faster climate change and faster sea level rise to sink the homes, businesses and real estate of hundreds of thousands who live on San Pedro Bay, from LB's swank Lower East Side to the less wealthy of Wilmington to much of the Port of LB itself.

John
First of all it's the Gerald Des- mond Bridge. Aside from being more elegant, How will the new bridge do for the average citizen? It will make it easier to dump more trucks onto the already nearly useless 710 which means that air quality and traffic congestion will get worse. It will expand the port into more and more real estate to the detri- ment of current occupants. Who needs an elegant "world class icon" if the only beneficiary is the 800 pound gorilla in the harbor?

Got Traffic
It is easy for you to say and want a iconic structure. Are you willing to pony up the money?

Joseph E
I'm all for good architecture, and I love bridges. But unless there is easy pedestrian and bike access to the new bridge and the connecting roads, no one will be able to appreciate it up close. The current plans turn Ocean Blvd into an expressway from 710 and thru Terminal Island, with no direct access for bikes, and almost no way for pedestrians to cross. The plans should be changed to make it possible to walk or bike from Downtown Long Beach to San Pedro along Ocean Blvd. Currently there is no good bike path between the two cities; neither Anaheim nor PCH have bike lanes or good sidewalks over the LA river or thru Wilmington. I would also argue that the plans should integrate stops for bus service in Terminal Island and the port, so port employees and merchant sailors would have an alternative way of getting to and from work, or to the shopping and entertainment areas in downtown. The new plans will make it almost impossible for a bus to stop along the road on either side of this bridge. So, once they solve those problems, I'm all for letting a good architect design us a stunning, beautiful bridge. But the real beauty in a bridge is in the way it connects two places.

BrianU
In regards to the issue of funding. I am as about as concerned for finding the funds to make a more beautiful bridge as I was for them finding the money to build a new bridge versus retrofitting it. A decision was made based on there being an economic benefit to a new bridge. I only ask that we do this one right so that we are not looking to replace it again four decades from now.

WrigleyWriter
While I'm not a fan of the Sundial Bridge in Redding, I do agree that a public works project as massive as the Gerald Desmond Bridge replacement should serve as an icon to the City of Long Beach. In keeping with the Port's "marketed" image, I hope this new bridge is a monument not only to the visual, but also as a demonstration of unique ways to use recycled and low-impact materials. Wouldn't it be cool to have the "greenest" bridge in the world?

G. Swanson
A structure on this scale should frame the southwestern edge of the city but also support the values that we are working towards: clean air, alternative transportation and art.

Greggory
No question if we're going to invest in such a project it ought to be iconic - and not another icon of the LBC missing an opportunity (e.g., the Aqua Towers). And after all, one of our main needs is for our city to become more of a destination from outlying areas - and an attractive, memorable gateway could only help with that.

Lupi
My family members are unemployed and struggling. We live only 8 miles away from the project. Where do we apply or send our resumes?

Design In Place
Brian Ulaszewski searches for sense of place in the built environment and the social architecture that is created through it. He will investigate the urban context of Long Beach and its wider relation to global, regional and local change.

Brian Ulaszewski practices architecture, planning and urban design in Long Beach, projects ranging in size and scope from city master planning to small loft conversions. He has a background in architecture, historic preservation, transportation and land-use planning. Brian is a member of the Long Beach Design Forum and a board member of the Gateway Cities Affordable Housing Coalition. (photo credit: Russ Roca)

Brian's Community

Bikestation Long Beach
Long Beach Affordable Housing Coalition
Brian's Archives

January, 2012

01.09.12 People versus Parking

December, 2011

12.20.11 A Better Alley

Show All Archives


About Us | Contact Us | Policies