| Sunday, March 14, 2010 | Home |
|
![]() |
|
Can You Have Your Advocacy & Eat It, Too? by Judy & Kate | Pet Post | 10.19.09 | | Text Size: +
The Pet Post was conceived as a pet column, but once you’ve really
loved an animal, you may find yourself investigating and defending
ferals and strays, advertising adoptions of animals that some may
consider odd (we don’t—see this week’s Virtually Pets), thumping the
president for not adopting a mutt, and worrying about the birds of the
air, fish in the sea and bears doing God knows what in the woods. Speaking of fish in the sea, a couple of weeks ago, the Press-Telegram published an article titled “PETA criticizes Aquarium of the Pacific over fish-eating promotion.” The Aquarium had launched its “Seafood for the Future” program to encourage partner restaurants to serve sustainable seafood, i.e., fish whose breeding or catching does not hurt them or their ecosystem and environment. Tracy Reiman, executive president of PETA, sent a letter to Dr. Jerry Schubel, the Aquarium’s CEO and president, urging him to drop the program, stating that encouraging people to eat fish, sustainable or otherwise, goes against the Aquarium’s mission of instilling “a sense of wonder, respect, and stewardship for the Pacific Ocean, its inhabitants, and ecosystems.”
We wondered how Dr. Schubel felt about a perceived contradiction of
being an advocate for animals and their environment and while
recommending eating certain of them. His response to Tracy Reiman
referred to the “daunting task” of changing a population’s behavior.
His response focused mainly on the environment and the health of people
who consume seafood, but not on the creatures themselves.We have two disclaimers: Kate’s a member of the Aquarium, and both of us support PETA’s mission, which addresses the relief and prevention of animal cruelty in any way possible through education, legislation, investigation and protest, among other things. Their acronym spelled out is People for the Ethical Treatment of Animals; veganism isn’t underscored on the Web site, but members definitely consider the philosophy an ethical one. Veganism is vegetarianism’s more evolved relative. The word vegan was coined in 1944 from the first two syllables of vegetarian—or “the beginning and end of vegetarian,” as defined by the founders of the Vegan Society . Vegans neither eat flesh nor use or eat any animal products—no honey, dairy, eggs or gelatin, and no leather, wool, fur, skin or scale. A friend was recently trying to place a quote that went something like “When you make the decision to eat, you will kill something.” She thought it was by Alan Watts, but wasn’t certain. Something that Watts did say, however, was, “Never pretend to a love which you do not actually feel,” and that’s unarguable. Both these sayings are food for thought for us—pun intended—after reading about the exchange between PETA and the Aquarium. You wash bacteria from food, you consume them when you eat yogurt, you absently swat at an annoying insect. And it’s good and educational to ask people to change their diet to avoid killing animals, but not to demand it. That turns people away. And a big question: No matter how many pets you rescue, no matter how many circuses or Eagles football games you boycott, are you an animal advocate if you eat seafood, or any other animal? Compassionate Cuisine is an annual Long Beach event, held this year in the lovely setting of the Earl Burns Miller Japanese Gardens as a celebration of World Vegetarian Day. It featured special guests, music by Makena and the Irvine Young Concert Artists, a raffle featuring ecofriendly items and services and all the vegan food samples you could consume. The prizes and food were donated by local vendors, and all the funding went to Animal Acres, a wonderful farm animal sanctuary in Acton. We figured that it would be an interesting place to ask our questions at Compassionate Cuisine because it’s attended by those who eschew meat and those who chew it. And if we didn’t get any answers or interesting opinions, we could at least eat real good (vegan cuisine is tasty and you won’t miss meat; with no blood dripping off the product, it’s much nicer, indeed). And we did—we had seconds on the nondogs at the Frankenstand and had to restrain ourselves after gulping down an avocado-based Chocolate Fudge Bite from Good to Go restaurant. We spoke with Linda Treffry, a solid and active Long Beach advocate for spay/neuter and adopting shelter dogs. Her own sweet dog is an abandoned one that she stopped in the middle of the street to pick up and take home with her. “You don’t have to be vegan or vegetarian to be an advocate for animals,” Treffry said. “I buy meat and eggs, but I refuse to eat meat from factory farms. They’re unsanitary and brutal.” Kimberly Zimmerman, an employee of Good to Go and dispenser of the irresistible Chocolate Fudge Bites, knows, as a foodie and developing vegan, the difficulty of changing eating habits, even as an animal advocate. “It’s a little challenging,” she said. “If you’re supporting the rights of animals, it’s contradictory to eat them. But there are ways you can consume animals that won’t affect a lifestyle as an activist.” “You want to be more like Gandi about it,” agreed vegan Susan Helms, who traveled extensively in the Buddhist country of Thailand and still found meat products sold and served there. “You want to live by example. My fiancé is involved in rescue and eats meat. He gets really defensive if people get in his face about it.” Long Beach resident Peter Rosenwald said he sympathizes with PETA’s efforts. “I don’t like people getting in my face, but I understand why they have their beliefs,” he said. “I think that we can do a better job of being animal advocates by becoming vegan. A little excess in the spirit of animals is good.” There are few people with greater proactive love for all animals than Lorri Houston, Animal Acres’s founder. Lorri’s been rescuing farm animals for about 18 years. She founded Animal Acres six years ago, and she and the volunteers have saved hundreds of animals from the slaughterhouse and went to New Orleans to help rescue animals during Hurricane Katrina. Houston also came to veganism gradually through a series of epiphanies. “Animal advocacy comes in all shapes and sizes,” she said. “and there comes a day when someone will want to save a chicken or pig as well as a dog or cat. Opening your hearts and minds will bring people in, not criticism or judgment.” (More disclaimers: Judy is a confirmed vegan, who weeps at the thought of the lowliest barnacle ripped from a reef. Kate still eats most seafood, but until she succumbs to the salmon fighting upstream in the currents of her resisting mind, plans to be more conscious of consuming only sustainable seafood.) If you’re vegecurious, check out Zephyr Vegetarian Café, 340 E. 4th St., Long Beach, 90802, (562) 435-7113. If slaughterhouses had glass walls, everyone would be vegetarian. Lucky 13 for Missy!In a recent posting, we featured a photo of a 13-year-old (we think, but it’s debatable) longhair Chihuahua named Missy who was left in the shelter by her terminally ill owner. We all bonded with her, especially Judy and ACS public health associate Debra Brubaker, and there was a huge effort to get her a home before her time ran out. Two Pet Post readers from Oregon, Barbara and Keith Cordes, used to live in Long Beach (note Keith’s shirtsleeve in the photo!) and had adopted a lab, also 13, at the shelter when it was still located on Willow Street. They saw Missy on the Pet Post, and Keith got into his car and drove down here to spring Missy, “with only minutes to spare,” as Brubaker described Missy’s reprieve. As we’re writing, Missy and Keith are heading back home, where Barb is no doubt making up a little Chihuahua bed and baking homemade bone biscuits. “I am so happy for her!” Brubaker said. Judy’s still speechless. If any of you have been considering saving Missy, there’s plenty more where she came from. Cats, too. And bunnies…. (Incidentally, the two fat cats we featured twice who were staying at Chewsy Dogs have gone home—both of them with the same person! Hope she has plenty of kibble on hand and lots of exercise toys!) ![]() Bye! And thanks! Virtually Pets: Adoption ![]() Here’s my headshot. Do I get the part? If you love Chihuahuas and missed out on Missy, this little guy is available. This 2-year-old male is shy at first, but once he knows you, he’s all-over hugs and kisses. He loves to go for walks. He’s living temporarily in kennel 718 at ACS, 7700 East Spring St., Long Beach (562) 570-PETS. His name? He’ll tell you! Wholesome food, love and a safe place to sleep. Namaste. This little fellow is one of five male Dumbo rats (need we describe the genesis of the breed name?) who was abandoned at a rented home. All of them just squeaked by getting poisoned by the new tenant when our very own rodent lady picked them all up. They’re ready for a loving home. If you can provide one, contact rodentlady44@yahoo.com. She’s a pet, not a wild animal. This gorgeous creature was found by the Nature Center staff at El Dorado Park, where folks dump their bunnies after Easter. Make her yours forever—contact rodentlady44@yahoo.com. Boxer Briefs: Animal Legislation City Council Meeting, Oct. 20 The Long Beach City Council will discuss several recommendations and changes to the city code that relate to reducing euthanasia and the number of unwanted animals through spay/neuter and microchipping, reducing animal impounds through licensing (cat licensing included), and expanding educational and volunteer programs to support Animal Care Services’ mission. The recommendations were introduced by Councilmembers Lowenthal, DeLong and O’Donnell. Meeting opens at 5 p.m. at the Council Chamber at 333 Ocean Blvd. To see Item 25 on the agenda, click here. Guv terminates anti-puppy mill bill Sadly, Governor Schwarzenegger vetoed AB 241 (Responsible Breeder Act), a desperately needed bill to curtail the overbreeding of animals in horrific living conditions at puppy mills. The governor’s veto statement is a smack in the face to his fellow legislators. The assembly passed the bill 59–17, and the senate passed it 25–9. The Long Beach City Council came out in unanimous support for the bill. Two things remain the same about Mr. Schwarzenegger: He’s still a bad actor and apparently cannot give up being the Terminator. One of the governor’s statements reads, "This measure simply goes too far in an attempt to address the serious problem of puppy mills. An arbitrary cap on the number of animals an entity can possess throughout the state will not end unlawful, inhumane breeding practices." AB 241 would have reduced the number of breeding animals at puppy mills, greatly reducing the suffering at facilities that have upward of 500 breeding animals. We can only hope that our next governor will understand the significant value a bill such as AB 241 carries for the fiscal and moral responsibility our legislators hold. Comments
Click Here to Leave a Comment
Margo C Of course the Long Beach Aquarium should NOT be serving fish on the menu. That is a no-brainer. As a vegetarian and member of FOLBA, I also support PETA's philosphies and activities. Thanks to Kate and Judi for this great article, including the happy pet stories. SS Judy & Kate: I agree with you wholeheartedly in the ethical treatment of animals. I will never become a vegan though. I applaud the aquarium in publishing information about more responsible types of seafood to eat that are not overfished in order to better protect the ecosystem of our oceans. If a seafood restaurant provides me with that information, then I will make a responsible choice when I order my food. I don’t mind being educated as to why I shouldn’t buy certain animal products such as leather and wool. As it happens, I have eczema and cannot tolerate wool in any of its forms, so I have no problems using man-made materials. And here’s a tidbit even you PETA people may not even know. Wool in its lanolin form is contained in almost every cosmetic product and pharmaceutical product out there. I would be happy if it disappeared as an ingredient in lotions, lipsticks, hair products, etc. I don’t own a leather sofa, but I own a man-made leather material type sofa because I didn’t want the maintenance hassle. If I could purchase meat at the supermarket that comes from a source that I knew was responsible in its production methods then I would, but I don’t have time to drive around to find those kinds of stores. Do you understand? So you need to tell PETA to tone it down a bit and stop preaching so much. Glad Missy found a home. katy I have to say I was not impressed with this article. I was expecting a discussion of the Aquarium vs. PETA issue, with arguments for both, but really got neither. Margo, the Aquarium does not serve seafood on premises. In fact, as stated in the article, this is an attempt by them to encourage their partner restaurants (I assume the ones at the Pike) to serve only sustainable seafood, which sure sounds like it fits hand-in-hand with PETA's mission of education. No matter what, people are going to eat fish, as they have done for centuries, so isn't it better to encourage them to eat fish that are plentiful, are caught sustainably and in a way that has less impact on the environment, rather than not? I think attacking the AOP, with its well-documented support of its mission of conservation and education, is pretty silly. NA Disappointing read. Jill I support the Aquarium, not PETA John The quotes at the end made me angry... This was a waste of time. Birdman of long beach Missy: How thrilled I am that little sweetheart got adopted. Thank you Judy & Kate and Debbie Brubaker at animal services for helping her and saving her life. I am not sure my feelings about PETA. Where I lived before I fed all the cats in the alley each night behind me. The lady who managed the apartments was feeding cats in her court yard and upset someone and they started poisoning cats and leaving them by her door. I tried to get PETA involved and there only option for me was telling me to trap the cats in the alley and have them put to sleep. About Lucky -I was wondering if anyone could update me at all about Lucky the black lab that was left behind when my friend Joe was killed in his wheelchair by a hit and run driver a couple months ago. I produced legal papers showing Lucky was to come to me in the event that Joe died. Lucky even wore a tag I had made for her saying she was to come to me if joe died. The photographer for Greg Mellen the Press telegram Columnist photographed my legal papers. I went to the fire station and produced them right away and they made a copy of them. To this day not one person has ever contacted me. All I was ever told was that lucky was being kept at a undisclosed location. The ER nurse at St. Marys is the one that supposedly had possession of Lucky. The last I heard from Greg Mellen was that Lucky was even sent back to the fire station until a neighbor complained and still no one from the fire station ever contacted me as if I didnt exist. Its like a conspiracy and I dont understand in the least why everything was handled the way it was with Lucky. When Greg Mellen tried to get imformation for me from the ER nurse all she said to him in a e-mail after ignoring some of his calls and e-mails was that Lucky was somewhere where she is getting human interaction. Maybe if someone who reads this is a attorney they could be kind enough to give me some advice as there was no excuse for everyone to treat me in such a manner. I can be contacted at animalrescuer131@yahoo.com I am a good person and my whole life is revolved around rescuing and helping animals so none of this makes any sense to me. I want the best for Lucky and love her dearly and it would be nice to see her. The Governor : About the governor not helping the poor tortured dogs in puppy mills is beyond me to ever understand. Maybe if he would go spend a week at a puppy mill he might feel differently and I wonder if he even has a animal of his own. Nikol Aww pretty pups, I want one! I dont agree with PETA at all & I didnt really understand this article puprose. But I do know the aquarium does wonderful things & I hope they continue. Summer Newsflash, PETA does not believe in the "ownership" of any animal. That includes dogs and cats and all other living things. That includes sustainable and organic farms, and yes, even housing animals in the Aquarium of the Pacific. They believe that all house pets should be put to sleep. They are not on your side, and it is almost silly to me that so many animal lovers support PETA. You need to look more into their organization, thier agenda is not yours. Kate K Yes, well--those of you who actually took time to suggest this article's shortcomings are much appreciated. I take full credit for trying to meld two situations, Aquarium/PETA and Comp, with fish glue. Apparently it didn't hold. What we were trying to bring across, and admittedly fell short of doing so, was that we have two organizations, each with its own view of advocacy, and they're at loggerheads regarding the subject of seafood. I myself had a problem with PETA telling another organization to recommend a philosophy or agenda--I have a problem with that regarding anything. I also wondered whether rescuing and adopting cats and dogs, marching in support of Prop. 2, or doing anything to help animals in general, are all negated if the people still eat any form of animal life, for whatever reason. Any behavior change comes out of education or epiphany. To use another animal adage, you can lead a horse to water--you know the rest. And, like any other question, there may be a couple of semisolid answers, but plenty of opinions. I'm glad that some debate resulted from it, though, which it should. To add to it, I have to comment on Summer's posting. PETA certainly does believe that there's no ownership of pets any more than you can have ownership of children. You're responsible for them. But as soon as I read the "house pets put to sleep" sentence, I saw death panels. There's something else going on with this post. PETA is an organization that is ceratinly aggressive and out of the box when it comes to animal rights--my favorite comment is from board member Bill Maher (and anything he's on a board of, I'm dandy with): "[PETA members] are staunch supporters who believe that you have to cross the line sometimes just to know where the line is."--they've done a lot to raise consciousness about animal rights. Check the Web site and decide for yourself. B1 Interestingly enough they do serve burgers at the zoo and there seems to be little complaint about that (or maybe there was one and I missed it) so why not fish at the aquarium!? Michael I have long believed that PETA is what would be called in the intelligence community, a "false flag operation." I suspect they are funded, in majority, by people OPPOSED to sensible animal rights ideas, and engage in absolutely ludicrous campaigns designed to make ALL people concerned with animal issues look ridiculous. Keith and Barb Judy and Kate...Missy up date, she is doing super, getting friskier every day. Our old Lab and Peek have taught her the treat trick. She loves exploring our back area of oue 1/2 acre. She gets a tooth pulled in AM, her cough is almost gone so she can go to our groomer and get fancied up. If I had an adress I could send some pics. Thanks for letting us get her.... Judy C. TO KEITH AND BARB: Thank you for the update on Missy! We are thrilled that she is doing well and adjusting to her new surroundings with ease. She is a truly, dear animal and very lucky you two came into her life! Thank you again for saving her.We would love to see photos of her! Please send them to Deb, at Long Beach Animal Care Services. Keith and Barb Judy and Kate...Thanks I will send the pics to Debra. As I peck away Missy is under the desk. She follows me every where Again thank you for what you do, saving little precious souls.God bless........... Kate K And thank you, Keith and Barbara, for schlepping all the way down here from Oregon in a rainstorm to get her. This week, Mutts comics is featuring pet adoption and volunteering, and even Marmaduke adopted (too many) dogs from the shelter and brought them to his doghouse. The lot of you set a wonderful example! Judy Griffith Yea, The 5 male Dumbo Rats found a good home. All together. And the Nature Center female Rabbit found home as of today tuesday. Now I have a female Holland Lop, allready spayed. That needs a home ASAP.Trying to keep her out of Animal Control. Summer PETA's national and international policies on pit bulls speaks for itself. It's the only breed of dog they can get away with touting a policy of mass extermination with out their members giving up on them. The large amount of members should start paying attention and be more vocal on what the focus of the organization is. The potential of PETA is squandered with too much focus being put on fly swatting and eco-friendly fish cook offs. My favorite organization today is Best Friends Animal Society. If you are going to donate money for a pro-animal cause, it is much better spent there. Congrats on the new adoptions! Peace. Kate K Best Friends is a wonderful, spirit-based organization as well. Any animal welfare organization that is truly directed at welfare is worthwhile. It depends on how you think and feel; you need to inform yourself on it all. kind of like religion. Peace back, Summer. Marie What a great post! People who bash PETA are really just misinformed by the CCF (Center for Consumer Freedom) which is organization that is paid for by large corporations who are scared by the headway that PETA has made the past 30 years. They are the largest animal rights organization who have saved countless animals by turning people vegetarian through their brave and risky undercover investigations on factory farms. They have also stopped many companies from testing on animals, including automobile companies who used to use animals in crash tests. They are large, so of course they have enemies, but the enemies should be the large corporations who have money to gain from factory farming, not animal lovers. Kudos to PETA and thank you, Judy and Kate for this post! Claire I volunteer at my local shelter and am surrounded by animal lovers. Some eat meat, some don't. I'm vegan and I don't think the meat eaters are hypocrites, I just think they aren't aware of the conditions. Slaughterhouses aren't exactly easily accessible and schools don't take field trips there. I was an animal lover all my life, but wasn't vegan until I watched PETA's "Meet Your Meat" and soon afterward went to a rescued farm animal sanctuary. After that it just clicked, but I know that everyone's threshold is different. I thank PETA though for educating me, and continuing to do so. Thanks for this post! Margo C Several years ago when I toured the Long Beach Aquarium, fish sandwiches were being offered in the food area. I was so horrified with that menu offering, I have never returnefd. If they have taken fish off the menu, hurray for the Long Beach Aquarium.
Pet Post
Judy and Kate unleash thoughts on pet care, animal rights and welfare, adoption and animal-related events in the area.
Judy lives in Long Beach with her husband, Dan and their three canine family members. Judy has been an active volunteer with various animal welfare work and issues since 1998, primarily focusing on pet overpopulation and humane education. She is a proud mother and grandmother, and loves spending time with her family. Kate is a 15-year Long Beach resident, and has a passion for anything involving animals or words. She is an active member of Friends of Long Beach Animals and believes that owner responsibility is the key to solving animal issues. She lives with two fat foundling felines.
Kate & Judy's Favorite Links
animalacres.org farmsanctuary.org folba.org goldenstatehumanesociety.org hautedogs.org hsus.org lcanimal.org peta.org petfinder.com socialcompassioninlegislation.org
Kate & Judy's Archives
March, 2010 03.09.10 Not Just A Pretty Face: Bulldog Rescue & ResponsibilityFebruary, 2010 02.24.10 Furry, Soft Speed Dating: Valentine’s Day At ACS 02.15.10 Brown Pelicans Suffering Another Mysterious Illness 02.09.10 Technology Helps Prevent Losing A PetJanuary, 2010 01.28.10 ACS Report Card: A+, With Room For Improvement 01.19.10 Life On The Breakwater: Between A Rock & A Hard Place 01.11.10 Wheely Willy Memorial Service, Adoptions & MoreDecember, 2009 12.30.09 Little Hero Exchanges Wheels for Wings 12.18.09 In Memoriam: Dr. Loren Eslinger, Hero to AnimalsShow All Archives |
||
| About Us | Contact Us | Policies | ||