Wednesday, February 8, 2012

A Modest Proposal - Part 3B: Economic Development
by Sander Roscoe Wolff | | 05.14.09 | 
| Text Size:
+

Economic Development & The Business of Arts & Culture
The arts are a powerful catalyst for economic development.  A representative of the Austin Convention and Visitors Bureau said, “our established music scene is what drew the creative tech-types here in the first place.”  It has also created a world renowned week long music festival, SXSW. 
ADVERTISEMENT
/>Economic development, in order to attract and retain businesses in specific sectors, can create tax exemptions, fee reductions, and even active promotional programs.  If the City is serious about creating a significant role for arts and culture, we should start thinking about the arts in terms of business. 

One artist I know rents a store front which she uses as a studio.  She stores materials there, and creates work, but doesn’t sell her work there.  The City now requires her to pay $300 per year for a business license.  It doesn’t sound like much money but, for most artists, it is. 

Musical instrument repair shops and retailers, theatre groups, museums, independent recorded music and book stores, art supply stores, music recording and video production studios, performance venues, and art galleries could benefit from tax exemptions and fee reductions.  Their bottom lines are so fragile that any economic relief can mean the difference between success and failure.  If we choose to recognize these businesses as valuable cultural assets, if we understand that their presence here significantly impacts the quality of life for all residents, and acts as a magnet for tourism, then we can justify allowing them some relief. 

Here’s one example:  The last time I checked, entertainment permit fees were about $1500 per year.  For a huge restaurant, that’s an insignificant investment.  For smaller restaurants, however, that’s a quite a financial hit.  It makes sense to base the fees on occupancy so that smaller restaurants can present live, amplified music, and the City can have live entertainment in more venues. 

So, if we reduce or eliminate business license fees for individual artists, create tax incentives and fee reductions for arts-related businesses, and create a sliding scale for entertainment permit fees, our City will benefit significantly. 

Enacting such policies will not cost us anything in new expenditures, but may produce an insignificant reduction in revenues.  Any fiscal loss the City experiences will be made up by the blossoming of a new creative renaissance. 



Comments
Click Here to Join the Discussion on this Story

13 Comments so far.
DC Frankenfeld
Thank you Sander for explaining the business consequences of arts and culture. This amateur (meaning "for the love of it," not non-professional)musician admires the possibilities of the income created by arts. Here in Bixby Knolls, the arts are the only sector filling storefronts: The Richard Goad Shakespeare Theater, Historical Society, etc., etc. Most of these organizations have blossomed organically, with little city subsidy. Sounds like you have been reading Richard Florida's book.

shiborigirl
hear, hear! it's about time we start looking at art as a business (at least insofar as the city is concerned)! for myself, i've always seen it that way-i'd much prefer to make things people want to buy than be begging at the doorstep of arts organizations for my $. but then again, i've always been a "sellout" and always will be. writing this from japan where i am on a silk study tour connecting with japanese artists and makers and learning oh-so-much. haven't had a second to post the goings on on the blog yet but hopefully will get to it this weekend-so far have seen master dyers, master weavers,master shibori makers, rescued some very important historical shibori design materials from certain doom. saw a filature mill, a tthe metropolitan research institute where silk fiber is tested and studied for manufacturing,ichiku kubotas own museum and stunning works in tsugigahana,namd more. today is the sericulture farm where it all begins... marveling at the japanese's ability to mix art and commerce so gracefully. we definitely can do much better. mata-ne!

Scott Blumenthal
Very nice article. Good points made throughout. Now it gets down to proper politicalness to get things done. Time to make it easier for all arts to flourish.

Sander
DC, I didn't need to read a book, or hire a consultant, to come up with these solutions. They're actually pretty obvious, especially in an environment where financial resources are steadily declining. SG, thank you for the report from the other side of the world. I look forward to all your pictures.

steel parade
ive known of these permit fees for years. it is what it is. that is how i know Long Beach, the city i was born and raised. theres lots of talk, but until these well entrenched laws and policies are changes, i really dont see any real change. as a full time musician, i have had the unique experience of performing civic events for almost every city in SoCal. this type of over-permitting doesnt happen in the other cities, and if it does, i dont encounter it. only do we find it here in my beloved city of Long Beach. in our band, we giggle, and laugh when the topic of performing in Long Beach is presented. its often followed by the statement "did they pay the $1500 for us to perform?", or the classic "its Long Beach, so nobody is getting paid". weve been offered more money for our services in every other city but Long Beach....and thats cool. it is what it is. Long Beach has a group of people who promote live entertainment, and dont offer money for the performance. this isnt an absolute, but it is the norm. once again, we do not experience this in Dana Point, Cerritos, Yucaipa, etc. so, until those permit fees go away, and also the so called art promoters who dont offer any substantial money for the bands that do perform in this city, i really dont see any change. finally, before you go and attack my comments.....please take a moment to size up who we are. we are FULL TIME musicians that are not trust fund babies, no day jobs, and have been doing this full time for close to 20 years in SoCal. as always, i thank you for this opportunity to express freely.

Sander
SP, I know a number of full time musicians, and playing in what I'd call 'entertainment' bands, with professional musicians playing a list of popular songs in a variety of styles, is nothing to be ashamed of. It takes the same amount of hard work and music chops as it does to play in a real band, one with original songs, and a following. <ok, so I'm teasing you just a bit.> The only criticism I have is of what seems to be an acceptance of the status quo. The only thing standing in the way of change is apathy. - Scott, as always, I really appreciate your insights and participation. The ideas are out there. Now all we need to do is call our elected representatives, send them emails and letters, asking for what we believe will work.

Sander
BTW, I was wondering if anyone was able to identify the background of the graphic at the top of the story.

steel parade
Sanders, i do remember the masterfully created songs and absolutely incredible chops of the real band known as Blue Dot. i felt ashamed after being exposed to such and impressive display of musicianship........im teasing, im teasing... in regards to apathy, i think a bit of apathy is to be expected given the current situation. i dont really accept the status quo as you stated, rather i simply go elsewhere. thank you for allowing me to express freely.

shiborigirl
sanders- are you really serious?? you said "Now all we need to do is call our elected representatives, send them emails and letters, asking for what we believe will work. " if that's all i thought it would take i don't think we would even be having this conversation right now. please...it's this kind of nonsense that continues to keep us on the path we are on. write, call and email our representatives?? no, this is NOT what it takes. it takes much more than that. so much more. you say that the only thing standing in the way of change is apathy. ok. so what is the cause of this apathy? i have answered this question for myself but until many more people find this answer out for themselves and we agree to solve the problem together then we will go nowhere. still writing from japan where i will visit the homes and studio workshops of 2 more master artisans next week where i am continuing my discussions and searching for more answers to questions relating to this on an international level. (by the way, i hate the interface on the comment section here. box is too small to go back and reread what one has written and there is no preview availabe- or maybe it's just me)

Sander
I'm serious. I actually believe in Democracy. The ideas I outlined are sound, and will produce clear and positive results if implemented. The elected members of our municipal government will take no action if they do not feel supported by their constituents. Thus, if we present them with both the ideas, and the support, they'll implement them. That's the way government works. Of course, it would help if more than 20% of the local electorate participated in local elections.

steel parade
shiborigirl, how can you be so naive. dont you know how Democracy works? hehehehe...

Viking Vixen
Good job, Sander. You actually got the city manager to acknowledge the problem with permitting live music. Stay on it, make the contacts that Pat West suggested and this could actually move forward. Also, I think the Arts Council is well aware of their disconnect with Long Beach artist and are moving toward change. Thanks for being tenacious!

shiborigirl
sp- of COURSE I know how democracy works! why do you think I have voted in every election (lg & sm) since I was 18-hey, wait a minute-why the hell HAVE I....? maybe THAT's the answer- TOTAL apathy! I'm moving closer to it every day. -back from Japan where it's not only the upper class who have the ability to experience beauty on a daily basis in one form or another and where people are kinder in general. not to mention a practice of self imposed responsibility. i believe the answers are bigger and simpler than we think. start with education-that's my best advice.


Sander lives with his wife, step-daughter, dogs, and cats. He's an avid photographer, and enjoys creating close-up images of flowers and plants, and capturing urban landscapes. He's been involved in music production since the early 80's, and worked professionally as an audio engineer, live sound mixer, and producer.

Sander Roscoe Wolff is a musician, artist, and was co-founder and Executive Director of LongBeachCulture.org, the City's first comprehensive, and free, arts calendar and registry.

He has served on the boards of the 2nd City Council Art Gallery + Performance Space and the East Village Arts District, curated a 6 month gallery exhibition in the Long Beach World Trade Center, and produced Songs For Bethune, a CD of original and traditional holiday songs by local artists, to raise funds for the Arts Council's Passport to the Arts program.

His work has been featured in local gallery exhibitions, in SoundWalk, and L.A. Siggraph's Photon Ballet.

His current music project is Ain Soph Aur, a systems based improvisational performance duo and studio team.

Sander's Community

Food Finders
Foodbank of Southern California


About Us | Contact Us | Policies